help ID messy eye shadow makeup

Hi,
Can anyone ID this eye shadow makeup? is it from skinbuilder or is it an overlay style makeup? i think LIE is what they are called? i have the makeup on one of my characters but its part of the face texture. So if i try to apply the makeup to another character with different body skins it replaces only the face makeup and i dont want that. The characters i saw them on are from two different vendors. So i'm hoping that its an overlay type makeup of some sort. I just havent had any luck with the search terms i'm putting in.
The top one is the one i have and its slightly different from the bottom one. I guess they used something to make the top part of it bigger like maybe two sets of eyeshadow overlapping.
Comments
I think quite a few characters come with similar messy makeup options. If you let us know where you got the images of the bottom character it might help narrow it down.
https://www.daz3d.com/realistic-tears-for-genesis-8-and-genesis-3 and a preset called mascara_smudged_b comes close but I don't think it's the exact one, hope you find what you're looking for.
That one might actually be better than the one i showed even if its not the same exact one. Its just hard to tell because of the hairstyle on the model which is covering up the sides of the mascara.